In Reply to: Survival of SACD and Survival of the Discerning Listening Experience posted by DkB on May 18, 2006 at 10:32:46:
"For me, I find it ridiculous to feed a great amplifier and speaker system with a CD source. A good system just shows up how constricted and strangled CD sounds when attempting to reproduce music."Having recently invested much effort in modifying my CD/SACD player, I have concluded that it's possible for RBCD replay to rise well above the threshold of nuanced musicality that you're referring to. But there are probably just a handful of products that can take RBCD to this level. What's puzzling is that though RBCD playback has only recently reached a superlative level of performance, it is possible for the first time with the best new players, to hear some older CDs sounding great(e.g. those mastered from the mid-1990s on).
Yes, SACD and vinyl are closer to the Absolute Sound, but the latest RBCD playback is incredibly good. I too have a big SACD and vinyl collection primarily in jazz. But I've pretty much stopped buying SACDs, because the difference in sonics between SACD and RBCD in my system is almost a matter of taste. And this is not due to any shortcomings in electronics. The sad thing is just how much harder it is to get a digital front end up to the level of other components in an audio system.
Dave
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Re: Survival of SACD and Survival of the Discerning Listening Experience - Dave Garretson 14:34:14 05/18/06 (12)
- Right on, I agree, RBCD has improved tremendously with SOTA players - Sordidman 16:42:06 05/19/06 (0)
- Re: Survival of SACD and Survival of the Discerning Listening Experience - Ozzie 13:24:59 05/19/06 (0)
- the difference in sonics between SACD and RBCD in my system... - Allen Wright 15:05:54 05/18/06 (2)
- Re: the difference in sonics between SACD and RBCD in my system... - Dave Garretson 15:41:54 05/18/06 (1)
- Believe it! - Allen Wright 12:40:13 05/19/06 (0)
- "older CDs sounding great" - Christine Tham 14:55:00 05/18/06 (6)
- Re: "older CDs sounding great" - sgb 22:41:37 05/18/06 (5)
- Sadly, you are right ... - Christine Tham 23:15:14 05/18/06 (4)
- Re: Sadly, you are right ... - Steve Siener 14:18:45 05/19/06 (3)
- Actually, no - Christine Tham 20:14:37 05/19/06 (2)
- I meant that it complements common iPod use: - Steve Siener 15:31:44 05/20/06 (1)
- Not sure about that - Christine Tham 16:52:28 05/20/06 (0)