In Reply to: Survival of SACD and Survival of the Discerning Listening Experience posted by DkB on May 18, 2006 at 10:32:46:
Hi DkB,I agree with most of your comments, but I don't see any great cause for alarm. SACD, although it has been relegated to niche format status, is not going away anytime soon despite the drone from the whining naysayers. After all, there's really not much to be gained from having all the current pop drivel released on SACD. Nor is there much to be gained from having most of the 60's/70's rock music remastered for release as SACDs; it was just too poorly recorded.
Being a niche format does have its benefits. For instance, classical music is sort of in its own niche as it's appeal seems to be lost to all that haven't had the exposure, or just aren't able or willing to listen. Producers of classical music aren't expecting platinum sales anyway, and if releasing their recordings as SACDs will help to ensure a certain amount of exposure through those seeking the highest quality of musical reproduction, then they will want to continue to benefit from that symbiotic relationship.
The same, of course, holds true for jazz. Jazz and classical are for people willing to take the time to listen. For those that aren't, there's the ultra convenience of the IPOD, and the CDs they carelessly toss about on their floors and in their cars.
I fully understand what you're saying about vinyl, which is part of the reason I'm still using my 25-year-old Thorens TD126. I'm in the midst of a serious search for a new TT though. I have too many great LPs to leave in the rack collecting dust.
BTW, did you catch the review and follow-up review of the Lindemann 820 in issue 24 of Positive Feedback?
W
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Re: Survival of SACD and Survival of the Discerning Listening Experience - Waldteufel 11:35:41 05/18/06 (25)
- Redbook sounds fine on my system, especially massed strings. - SalD 16:26:52 05/18/06 (24)
- Sounds like that's player/music specific; not format specific - Waldteufel 22:18:35 05/18/06 (2)
- Re: Sounds like that's player/music specific; not format specific - SalD 22:40:57 05/18/06 (1)
- Where I Struggle With That - Robertc88 03:52:14 05/19/06 (0)
- I read an article in the absolute sound many years ago that stated many components are being designed with CDs in mind. - Teresa 16:41:02 05/18/06 (20)
- I would like to purchase equipment that is honest to the recording. - Robert Hamel 07:28:30 05/19/06 (0)
- Don't know about that, but ... - Christine Tham 17:26:59 05/18/06 (18)
- A further hint ... - Christine Tham 18:10:16 05/18/06 (17)
- Well, - Steve Siener 19:52:47 05/18/06 (16)
- Re: Well, - Christine Tham 21:11:38 05/18/06 (15)
- Theory vs. Practice - Dave Garretson 08:56:35 05/19/06 (14)
- Re: Theory vs. Practice - Christine Tham 15:31:24 05/19/06 (13)
- Still overlooking digitals poorest design solution. - Frank.. 11:08:53 05/22/06 (0)
- I'm not following you - Charles Hansen 21:14:38 05/20/06 (2)
- I'll try and explain it as simply as I can, but it is a lot easier if i can draw a picture - Christine Tham 22:01:19 05/20/06 (1)
- Re: I'll try and explain it as simply as I can, but it is a lot easier if i can draw a picture - Frank.. 11:30:45 05/22/06 (0)
- Re: Theory vs. Practice - Dave Garretson 07:29:47 05/20/06 (6)
- Re: Theory vs. Practice - Christine Tham 08:44:21 05/20/06 (5)
- Re: Theory vs. Practice - Dave Garretson 12:38:10 05/20/06 (4)
- Re: Theory vs. Practice - Christine Tham 17:16:10 05/20/06 (3)
- Re: Theory vs. Practice - iza 00:36:02 05/21/06 (2)
- Re: Theory vs. Practice - Christine Tham 00:48:13 05/21/06 (1)
- Re: Theory vs. Practice - iza 02:55:21 05/21/06 (0)
- Excellent thinking - The Sound Guy 00:42:56 05/20/06 (1)
- It's bad thinking.. - Frank.. 10:41:27 05/22/06 (0)