In Reply to: Where ya been John...you dissapeared after two people proved your tests wrong... posted by jneutron on March 24, 2004 at 14:17:28:
Who proved WHAT????Where in the world do you get your science from?
Neither Bruno or the other fellow have proven any such thing.
Their measurements, using their equipment, and their techniques, etc. failed to come up with the same measurement results as John C.
And so?
This does not prove that John Curl's measurements are somehow at fault, or are to be dismissed.
These other fellows measurement's were hardly presented in a peer-reviewed scientific journal, we were not privy to all the details and specifics.
How can you possibly claim that JC's measurements are faulty, based on two casual non-published results that probably did not fully duplicate his ?
The fact of the matter is, based on the accepted scientific practices, you can't.
Neither do you have any reasonable excuse for the "holier-than-thou" tongue lashing you dish out.
[ I designed cables..
I built them.
I tested them.
And it works.. ]
Gee, this sounds familiar. I tried explaining that to you, and what I got several times was that I was full of cr_p.
Only, I can add that my work included controlled listening tests.
Somehow, my years of experience as an audio industry engineer mean nothing, and your casual interest in audio is completely superceding.
You have no lock on the the truth, no leg up with regard to high end audio physics, and virtually no real experience with high performance audio playback. You criticisms are often off the mark, or overlook some relevant issue, or just plain don't make good audio sense.
When your clones of the patented Wireworld cables get the Noble prize, then you can call us, until then, stick to the lab work you know and lay off people who are in audio and know what good sound is from direct experience.
Jon Risch
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- What a crock! - Jon Risch 17:23:45 03/24/04 (8)
- OH geeze, another voice from the cheap seats.. - jneutron 06:44:49 03/25/04 (6)
- Re: OH geeze, another voice from the cheap seats.. - john curl 10:35:27 03/25/04 (5)
- What's that? speak up...boy, those seats are really back there... - jneutron 11:38:31 03/25/04 (2)
- OK,....uh ... sorry to interupt, but what websites, please.... - slope 15:35:41 03/25/04 (1)
- Re: OK,....uh ... sorry to interupt, but what websites, please.... - jneutron 07:29:06 03/26/04 (0)
- Re: OH geeze, another voice from the cheap seats.. - Steve Eddy 11:02:23 03/25/04 (1)
- Waaaaaaiiiiiiiitttttaaaammminute Steve.. - jneutron 11:56:21 03/25/04 (0)
- Re: What a crock! - Steve Eddy 18:42:29 03/24/04 (0)