In Reply to: this is, I believe, his point posted by tunenut on June 16, 2006 at 13:58:39:
HowdyI know, but without a filter your signal is corrupted even worse, think of the whole beating boondoggle.
I think he's being inconsistent. If you use a filter you get back your original waveform and if you dither you can get a little more. If you don't filter you don't get back your original waveform, (perhaps it's close enough) but if you dither you get a little more and why is it presumed that the lack of fidelity in the dithering is worse than that of the rest?
-Ted
(P.S. I know that in the limit we are talking DSD where the filter is critical, but his original claim was "Without filtering in D/A, dithering would not work" which just isn't true.)
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- I know, but - Ted Smith 14:12:42 06/16/06 (25)
- Maybe This Would Help.... - Todd Krieger 15:07:43 06/16/06 (19)
- ***sigh*** Same mistake you made years ago - real_jj 20:04:17 06/16/06 (2)
- Re: ***sigh*** Same mistake you made years ago - Todd Krieger 00:01:30 06/17/06 (1)
- So, like the guy at www.timecube.com, you won't go away... - real_jj 00:26:31 06/17/06 (0)
- That's misleading and actually wrong. - Ted Smith 15:28:54 06/16/06 (15)
- Re: That's misleading and actually wrong. - Todd Krieger 21:07:20 06/16/06 (14)
- Still the same mistake. - real_jj 22:21:43 06/16/06 (13)
- Re: Still the same mistake. - Todd Krieger 23:50:30 06/16/06 (12)
- Of course you can in many cases! - Ted Smith 07:39:37 06/17/06 (7)
- Bullshit.... - Todd Krieger 11:01:50 06/17/06 (6)
- Sorry Todd - Ted Smith 12:22:28 06/17/06 (2)
- Re: Sorry Todd - Todd Krieger 12:55:53 06/17/06 (1)
- Re: Sorry Todd - Ted Smith 13:03:49 06/17/06 (0)
- Tut... - real_jj 11:08:23 06/17/06 (2)
- The Poseur Posse.... - Todd Krieger 11:20:15 06/17/06 (1)
- See the questions addressed to you at the top of the board... - real_jj 11:30:37 06/17/06 (0)
- Well, let's see. - real_jj 00:20:18 06/17/06 (3)
- Re: Well, let's see. - Todd Krieger 00:51:57 06/17/06 (2)
- Re: Well, let's see. - andy_c 08:44:44 06/17/06 (0)
- Todd, go get a sub-director at www.timecube.com - real_jj 00:54:25 06/17/06 (0)
- Don't confuse oversampling with dithering... - real_jj 14:21:05 06/16/06 (3)
- Sorry I wasn't trying to - Ted Smith 14:32:35 06/16/06 (2)
- Understood... - real_jj 14:50:44 06/16/06 (1)
- Agreed - Ted Smith 15:05:56 06/16/06 (0)
- I see your point - tunenut 14:19:30 06/16/06 (0)