In Reply to: Bipolar vs MOSFET vs J-FET posted by thetubeguy1954 on January 26, 2007 at 05:58:39:
I posted the question on Tweaker's a while back about why wouldn't we want to use ceramics based on ESR, cost etc etc. By golly no one even mentioned linearity, and there was a whole bunch of handwaving too but nothing really satisfying like hearing: What about linearity? Based on the article you linked it has just hit me like a ton of bricks. Duh it's the linearity dummy. Thanks for posting that.Fet's, J & MOS, are nice for high impedance inputs but are not as linear as BJT's making them troublesome as input devices. BJT's low impedance giving great EMI resistance but also have very little current gain making them troublesome as output devices. There are tradeoffs with all of these and IMO it is up to the designer to choose the most appropriate tool for the job. Often a mix and match approach is best. For example a BJT front end with a MOSFET final stage is popular for obvious reasons.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Ah, the linearity. Duh! - Ugly 10:27:46 01/29/07 (61)
- Re: Ah, the linearity. Duh! - morricab 02:08:44 01/30/07 (59)
- Re: Ah, the linearity. Duh! - john curl 18:50:45 01/30/07 (3)
- It depends on what type of "tubes". - cheap-Jack 08:04:50 01/31/07 (0)
- Re: Ah, the linearity. Duh! - Dan Banquer 05:41:58 01/31/07 (1)
- If it sounds good, it doesn't matter to me solid or vacuum state. - cheap-Jack 08:11:53 01/31/07 (0)
- Re: Ah, the linearity. Duh! - Ugly 10:53:40 01/30/07 (1)
- Re: Here's one for you to try..... - hitsware 11:01:25 01/30/07 (0)
- News Flash! - Dan Banquer 05:48:25 01/30/07 (52)
- Re: News Flash! - morricab 03:36:52 01/31/07 (51)
- Re: News Flash! - Dan Banquer 04:21:01 01/31/07 (50)
- Re: News Flash! - bjh 08:54:10 01/31/07 (0)
- Re: News Flash! - morricab 06:57:38 01/31/07 (48)
- Re: News Flash! - Dan Banquer 07:47:55 01/31/07 (47)
- Re: News Flash! - john curl 08:40:04 01/31/07 (30)
- Re: News Flash! - theaudiohobby 10:39:26 01/31/07 (0)
- P.S. - Dan Banquer 09:23:54 01/31/07 (27)
- Re: P.S. - john curl 12:40:00 01/31/07 (23)
- Re: P.S. - Dan Banquer 15:58:46 01/31/07 (21)
- You're in good company - E-Stat 16:16:52 02/01/07 (20)
- Fools rush in - Dan Banquer 04:54:08 02/02/07 (19)
- Re: Fools rush in - john curl 12:03:42 02/02/07 (10)
- Re: Fools rush in - Dan Banquer 09:08:07 02/03/07 (7)
- Re: Fools rush in - john curl 12:05:38 02/03/07 (6)
- Re: Fools rush in - Dan Banquer 12:18:10 02/03/07 (5)
- P.S. - Dan Banquer 12:59:23 02/03/07 (4)
- Re: P.S. - john curl 15:59:04 02/03/07 (3)
- Boy, this is getting pathetic - E-Stat 08:04:50 02/04/07 (2)
- Depends on which Webster you are referring to... - Wellfed 10:32:07 02/04/07 (1)
- Not this one! - E-Stat 18:43:51 02/04/07 (0)
- Thanks for the breath of fresh air in this stale discussion - E-Stat 16:45:43 02/02/07 (1)
- Re: Thanks for the breath of fresh air in this stale discussion - john curl 17:41:18 02/03/07 (0)
- They sure did! - E-Stat 06:11:43 02/02/07 (7)
- As usual you............. - Dan Banquer 06:22:20 02/02/07 (6)
- The VTLs are not problematic high feedback designs, Dan - E-Stat 06:32:08 02/02/07 (5)
- You missed the point - Dan Banquer 06:37:08 02/02/07 (4)
- You continue to leave out the important qualifier - E-Stat 06:52:11 02/02/07 (3)
- P.S. - Dan Banquer 07:35:14 02/02/07 (1)
- "The issue is not negative feedback and never really has been" - E-Stat 07:56:03 02/02/07 (0)
- You really don't understand the issues involved. - Dan Banquer 07:07:18 02/02/07 (0)
- Oh he's real, ... - bjh 12:43:04 01/31/07 (0)
- Best cry I'd say, ... - bjh 09:56:03 01/31/07 (2)
- Re: Best cry I'd say, ... - theaudiohobby 10:36:15 01/31/07 (1)
- While purely speculation mind you, I'd be inclined to think that - bjh 11:51:10 01/31/07 (0)
- Re: News Flash! - Dan Banquer 09:02:07 01/31/07 (0)
- Re: News Flash! - morricab 08:39:10 01/31/07 (15)
- Special announcement! - Dan Banquer 09:11:17 01/31/07 (14)
- Re: Special announcement! - morricab 02:29:11 02/01/07 (11)
- Re: Special announcement! - john curl 08:34:07 02/01/07 (1)
- Re: Special announcement! - Dan Banquer 09:05:23 02/03/07 (0)
- Re: Special announcement! - Dan Banquer 04:23:24 02/01/07 (8)
- Re: Special announcement! - morricab 05:19:13 02/01/07 (7)
- Re: Special announcement! - Dan Banquer 08:16:19 02/02/07 (6)
- Re: Special announcement! - morricab 09:25:42 02/02/07 (5)
- Re: Special announcement! - theaudiohobby 01:27:57 02/03/07 (0)
- Re: Special announcement! - morricab 03:29:36 02/03/07 (3)
- Re: Special announcement! - theaudiohobby 05:09:08 02/08/07 (0)
- Re: Special announcement! - Dan Banquer 08:53:09 02/03/07 (1)
- Re: Special announcement! - morricab 14:16:33 02/03/07 (0)
- Re: Special announcement! - theaudiohobby 01:20:15 02/03/07 (0)
- Re: Special announcement! - john curl 12:21:54 01/31/07 (1)
- So What! nt. - Dan Banquer 04:25:01 02/01/07 (0)
- Linearity? Ever try a triodes-driving-MOS-FET power amp? - cheap-Jack 11:20:04 01/29/07 (0)