In Reply to: Bass management is *always* sound degrading posted by Christine Tham on November 30, 2005 at 22:52:12:
In the "document", page 45, I see"Only modest amounts of signal from specific instruments with significant low frequency content — kick drum, tympani, bass guitar, acoustic bass, low organ or piano notes — should be routed to the LFE, and in all instances those instruments should also be printed full range to the desired main channels as well."
That means that if you don't bass manage your main channels, and you use the LFE channel for the sub without matching the sub low-pass filter to the mains, you are hearing some excessive bass, between the low-pass frequency used in the LFE and your main channel's natural frequency cut-off. If engineers mix anything below 80Hz into the LFE, and floorstanders reproduce down to 35Hz, that is a lot of excessive bass between those frequencies.
Christine, I assume you have set the low-pass filter on the sub to match the speakers, then I agree, bass management is not needed.
My point was, with bass management, we could liberate the LFE channel, and make sacd 6.0 (and 6.1 with bass management at home). That would make the position of speakers a little easier, because covering 300deg with just 2 speakers is difficult.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Bass management or LFE low-pass filtering is required if using a sub - csuzor 08:18:06 12/01/05 (19)
- Re: Bass management or LFE low-pass filtering is required if using a sub - Christine Tham 14:50:03 12/02/05 (17)
- Re: Bass management or LFE low-pass filtering is required if using a sub - Robert C. Lang 18:26:34 12/02/05 (16)
- Bass management case study . . . - Martin419 10:34:18 12/03/05 (11)
- Re: Bass management case study . . . - Robert C. Lang 15:47:02 12/03/05 (8)
- Re: Bass management case study . . . - Martin419 04:26:23 12/04/05 (7)
- Re: Bass management case study . . . - Robert C. Lang 11:53:25 12/04/05 (6)
- Re: Bass management case study . . . - Martin419 12:26:35 12/04/05 (5)
- Re: Bass management case study . . . - Robert C. Lang 12:58:06 12/04/05 (4)
- Re: Bass management case study . . . - Martin419 05:42:53 12/05/05 (3)
- DVD-A and SACD - Robert C. Lang 15:14:01 12/05/05 (2)
- Re: DVD-A and SACD - csuzor 05:22:19 12/07/05 (1)
- Re: DVD-A and SACD - Robert C. Lang 09:25:24 12/07/05 (0)
- Thankfully, at least one engineer "gets it" (nt) - Dave Kingsland 13:52:35 12/03/05 (1)
- Re: Thankfully, at least one engineer "gets it" (nt) - Martin419 16:37:47 12/03/05 (0)
- Re: Bass management or LFE low-pass filtering is required if using a sub - Christine Tham 21:12:08 12/02/05 (3)
- Re: Bass management or LFE low-pass filtering is required if using a sub - Dave Kingsland 10:59:26 12/03/05 (1)
- That's not as bad as you think - Christine Tham 15:08:42 12/03/05 (0)
- Some examples of "surprising" results I found for my room ... - Christine Tham 22:16:11 12/02/05 (0)
- The LFE channel should not be used for music - Dave Kingsland 11:43:25 12/01/05 (0)