In Reply to: Re: Nope posted by Jim Austin on October 22, 2005 at 09:15:41:
Thanks for clearing up your meaning. Double blind actually has a different meaning in the wine world, but we do everything weird. Your definition is the one I will usehere.The sort of analytical tasting you ask about is done routinely. For example, someone wishing to judge in several of the major competitions must be able to demonstrate in a blind tasting that they can detect and identify threshold elements like volatile acidity, TCA taint, brettanomyces, and the like via spiked samples at known concentrations. Yes, ABX is used, but it's one of several analytical tasting formats. Duo-trio and triangle are even more common.
In my own work (wine packaging), we are specifically looking for differences in most of our tests, not just better/worse. Our sensory panel consists of people who, under double blind conditions, are reliably able to distinguish the differences we're testing for. And any test that we or our customers would take seriously must be run double blind.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Re: Yep - Mahatma Kane Jeeves 09:34:14 10/22/05 (15)
- Sounds like... - Jim Austin 12:10:35 10/23/05 (3)
- Another method for keeping tasters honest... - Mark Kelly 19:50:03 10/24/05 (0)
- Is the sense of taste more acute than the sense of hearing? - Dave Pogue 05:35:53 10/24/05 (0)
- Re: Sounds like... - Mahatma Kane Jeeves 21:31:29 10/23/05 (0)
- Now hold on there. - Silver Eared John 12:14:20 10/22/05 (8)
- Did someone say Zin? - mkuller 11:39:21 10/23/05 (4)
- I've liked the "Rodney Strong Twisted Vines" in the past - Silver Eared John 16:54:52 10/24/05 (0)
- Re: Dry Creek - Mahatma Kane Jeeves 21:32:19 10/23/05 (2)
- I have a few late-70s Zins that still hold up. Amazing! - clarkjohnsen 09:34:18 10/24/05 (1)
- Re: I have a few late-70s Zins that still hold up. Amazing! - Mahatma Kane Jeeves 13:04:45 10/24/05 (0)
- Re: No disagreement - Mahatma Kane Jeeves 16:11:13 10/22/05 (2)
- Hmm, anything I can still buy realistically that you like? - Silver Eared John 18:15:23 10/22/05 (1)
- Re: Hmm, anything I can still buy realistically that you like? - Mahatma Kane Jeeves 18:25:26 10/22/05 (0)
- Hey W.C.... - mkuller 10:26:29 10/22/05 (1)
- Re: Hey W.C.... - Mahatma Kane Jeeves 10:32:59 10/22/05 (0)