In Reply to: Peter Gabriel's So (LP, SACD) Shaking The Tree: 16 Golden Greats (CD, SACD) posted by Teresa on May 10, 2006 at 16:25:08:
I cannot speak for any LP version nor the Greatest hits package since I have never owned them. The CDs and SACDs from the rest of the catalog are a different story.Your complaints are the opposite of the impression myself and others have of these disks. If anything, the original CD version of "So", is often considered to be a bright sounding disk, hardly not rolled off. The SACD version is much more natural to my ears, but still not rolled off.
As a rule, PG recordings typically feature gobs of low bass, since his style includes a great deal of percussion and synths. The original CD version of Shock the Monkey from "Security" and the "Passion" disk , (which is the soundtrack from "The Last Temptation of Christ") were often used as reference material to judge bass performance. The is sub 50 hz information present and those passages (and many others), will provide a heavy duty workout for my Sunfire sub.
I stand by what I've said. PG works in general should in no way be considered low fidelity. Perhaps you have a bass management problem?
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- I still disagree... - joyzmantoyz 05:44:08 05/11/06 (20)
- No bass management problems I have full sized speakers with 12 inch woofers powered by 325 watts per channel. - Teresa 10:53:46 05/11/06 (19)
- "Don't Give Up" - with Kate Bush - Metralla 11:44:47 05/11/06 (18)
- What I would like to know is... - joyzmantoyz 13:00:36 05/11/06 (17)
- Actually here are some Rock albums that have good fidelity: - Teresa 17:27:12 05/11/06 (16)
- 2 more good sounding rock albums: Ten Years After: A Space In Time & Kinks: Muswell Hillbilly (nt) - Teresa 14:16:53 05/13/06 (0)
- Teresa's List... - joyzmantoyz 06:22:24 05/12/06 (12)
- You've both listed some good music, and you've both listed some well- and marginally well recorded albums... - Waldteufel 06:12:58 05/19/06 (0)
- Don't Give Up On Classical Music - Robertc88 03:46:30 05/13/06 (0)
- You asked me "What rock albums I think sound good", I answered, you attack my taste! - Teresa 15:21:16 05/12/06 (2)
- Judging by your comments here... - joyzmantoyz 07:33:45 05/13/06 (1)
- If anyone is an idiot it is you! You asked me a question, I answered honestly, you attacked - Teresa 14:10:08 05/13/06 (0)
- What a terrific post, mate - Metralla 08:43:13 05/12/06 (6)
- Metralla I am out of my element in Rock, but joyzmantoyz asked me what I Rock albums "I thought" sounded good. - Teresa 15:31:00 05/12/06 (0)
- Re: What a terrific post, mate - jharris 10:02:56 05/12/06 (4)
- Gald you all liked the post. - joyzmantoyz 10:29:11 05/12/06 (3)
- Re: Gald you all liked the post. - jharris 12:03:18 05/12/06 (0)
- Re: Gald you all liked the post. - jharris 11:14:04 05/12/06 (1)
- Actually I have the Nightfly on DVD-A - joyzmantoyz 11:37:57 05/12/06 (0)
- The Sheffield Track Album and The Sheffield Drum Album - what wonderful rock music (nt) - Metralla 17:31:48 05/11/06 (1)
- I gave 15 examples of good sound, why did you gravitate to those two? - Teresa 17:40:14 05/11/06 (0)