In Reply to: There's that silly comparison again... posted by String Section on May 9, 2006 at 11:50:11:
Most of us HAVE to compare...Why? There is no music on SACD. So, - one has to choose wisely when they come to a decision regarding SACD. This is especially true because of the lack of software, - if the software was all "good recordings," - whatever that means, - then it would be different.
Take for example the recording of "Jazz at the Pawnshop." There is at the very least, a ton of debate about the fact that the SACD layer is MUCH WORSE, - than the redbook layer. Or, - the Nora Jones SACD, - wherein the SACD layer was made from the Redbook layer...
Having listened to several of the crop of SACD players that in the $1,000 range, - there isn't ONE SACD CD that sounds as good as the same remastered recording in redbook through my APL, Meitner, etc.. AND EVEN the $2.5K Audio Aero Prima. If you take Peter Gabriel's remastered redbook and Peter Gabriel's remastered SACDs, - the redbook recording trounces ANY and all SACD players in the $1K range..
So, it is important to get the right thing....
"The men who own the city make more sense than we do: their actions are clear, their lives are their own"
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- That's the rub.... - Sordidman 12:12:36 05/09/06 (29)
- No music on SACD? - Ted Smith 12:23:27 05/09/06 (28)
- A few Peter Gabriel titles - Sordidman 13:03:39 05/09/06 (27)
- Ah Ha, that is how you can listen to CD! Rock music usually doesn't have massed strings. - Teresa 01:13:04 05/10/06 (26)
- As I mentioned, - Jazz at the Pawnshop - Sordidman 10:12:34 05/10/06 (1)
- Re: As I mentioned, - Jazz at the Pawnshop - Bruce from DC 10:57:31 05/10/06 (0)
- Anyone who can claim that Peter Gabriel recordings are - joyzmantoyz 08:52:08 05/10/06 (0)
- "his music is very low fidelity" - Metralla 06:09:32 05/10/06 (22)
- Peter Gabriel's So (LP, SACD) Shaking The Tree: 16 Golden Greats (CD, SACD) - Teresa 16:25:08 05/10/06 (21)
- I still disagree... - joyzmantoyz 05:44:08 05/11/06 (20)
- No bass management problems I have full sized speakers with 12 inch woofers powered by 325 watts per channel. - Teresa 10:53:46 05/11/06 (19)
- "Don't Give Up" - with Kate Bush - Metralla 11:44:47 05/11/06 (18)
- What I would like to know is... - joyzmantoyz 13:00:36 05/11/06 (17)
- Actually here are some Rock albums that have good fidelity: - Teresa 17:27:12 05/11/06 (16)
- 2 more good sounding rock albums: Ten Years After: A Space In Time & Kinks: Muswell Hillbilly (nt) - Teresa 14:16:53 05/13/06 (0)
- Teresa's List... - joyzmantoyz 06:22:24 05/12/06 (12)
- You've both listed some good music, and you've both listed some well- and marginally well recorded albums... - Waldteufel 06:12:58 05/19/06 (0)
- Don't Give Up On Classical Music - Robertc88 03:46:30 05/13/06 (0)
- You asked me "What rock albums I think sound good", I answered, you attack my taste! - Teresa 15:21:16 05/12/06 (2)
- Judging by your comments here... - joyzmantoyz 07:33:45 05/13/06 (1)
- If anyone is an idiot it is you! You asked me a question, I answered honestly, you attacked - Teresa 14:10:08 05/13/06 (0)
- What a terrific post, mate - Metralla 08:43:13 05/12/06 (6)
- Metralla I am out of my element in Rock, but joyzmantoyz asked me what I Rock albums "I thought" sounded good. - Teresa 15:31:00 05/12/06 (0)
- Re: What a terrific post, mate - jharris 10:02:56 05/12/06 (4)
- Gald you all liked the post. - joyzmantoyz 10:29:11 05/12/06 (3)
- Re: Gald you all liked the post. - jharris 12:03:18 05/12/06 (0)
- Re: Gald you all liked the post. - jharris 11:14:04 05/12/06 (1)
- Actually I have the Nightfly on DVD-A - joyzmantoyz 11:37:57 05/12/06 (0)
- The Sheffield Track Album and The Sheffield Drum Album - what wonderful rock music (nt) - Metralla 17:31:48 05/11/06 (1)
- I gave 15 examples of good sound, why did you gravitate to those two? - Teresa 17:40:14 05/11/06 (0)