In Reply to: Re: Besides speakers like Tom's posted by John Atkinson on December 14, 2006 at 15:38:14:
I don't see that we can review it, Steve. Yes, back in the 1960s,
Gordon Holt did write a short report on the Altec A-7. But other
than that, we have steered clear of sound reinforcement speakers.And I still don't get it, John.
Twice you've made mention of "sound reinforcement" yet I still have no idea exactly what this means as it relates to the SH-50's peformance in a home audio system and its disqualification for review consideration in Stereophile.
The only things that say "sound reinforcement" to me are its trapezoidal shape for easy arraying, and its industrial painted finish, neither of which have anything to do with its performance in a home audio system. In fact, I would argue that the SH-50's broadband, controlled directivity alone actually makes it more suitable for home audio than pretty much every other speaker Stereophile has reviewed.
Bottom line, beyond the trapezoidal cabinet shape and the industrial painted finish, what I see is something that was designed to be a high quality, high performance loudspeaker. Period.
So I'll say it once again. I don't get it.
Way too many domestic speakers deserving attention, IMO.You mean like the Tetra 505L TD?
se
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Re: Besides speakers like Tom's - Steve Eddy 20:17:53 12/14/06 (16)
- LOL: Good point! - Pat D 20:53:16 12/14/06 (15)
- So? - AJinFLA 15:42:34 12/15/06 (1)
- LOL - Pat D 15:53:01 12/15/06 (0)
- Re: LOL: Good point! - Steve Eddy 21:41:52 12/14/06 (12)
- Shucks rejected by JA's measurements, jeez maybe someone should tell these guys ... - bjh 08:53:20 12/16/06 (11)
- Re: Shucks rejected by JA's measurements, jeez maybe someone should tell these guys ... - John Atkinson 14:22:57 12/16/06 (1)
- Really? - bjh 16:26:47 12/16/06 (0)
- But JA also listened. - Pat D 09:37:30 12/16/06 (6)
- Pat-D-cake, did he do controlled DBTs? - bjh 09:56:58 12/16/06 (5)
- That's not *quite* as silly a question as it seems . . . - Pat D 10:41:11 12/16/06 (4)
- Pat-D-cake when you referred to yourself as a rationalist I almost pissed myself so quit reading just to be safe. nt - bjh 11:16:57 12/16/06 (3)
- Does this mean you're going to replace those good measuring Stratus Gold-i's with Tetras? - Pat D 14:50:01 12/16/06 (2)
- Pat-D-cake measurements are the very last thing that concern me in this hobby! Actually that's a lie ... - bjh 15:49:19 12/16/06 (1)
- If you don't care about measurements and DBTs, then why do protest against them so much? - Pat D 20:54:46 12/16/06 (0)
- Re: Shucks rejected by JA's measurements, jeez maybe someone should tell these guys ... - Steve Eddy 09:27:37 12/16/06 (1)
- Doubt many audiophiles bougth a Bose Acoustic Wave as result, what do you think? nt - bjh 10:00:37 12/16/06 (0)