In Reply to: The neglected factor: self-capacitance of coils ? posted by cheap-Jack on December 5, 2006 at 13:20:55:
First of all, I am very familiar with your writing style and this ain't it. Though you did mess up both the English usage and spelling in quite a few places, it's not enough to fool anyone. Why not provide a proper reference. I really don't understand your complete disdain for references.In any case, there is something that I don't completely understand. Maybe someone else can help me interpret it:
"If self-capacitance is too much, it will reduce the Q of the of the coil/winding ..."
That's simple enough, but this I don't get:
"... & will be worsen via the dielectric or insulation of the wire or interleaving between windings."
Is the author simply talking about the fact that the insulation has a dielectric factor greater than 1 (that of air)? If so, why not say what it is about the insulation that makes things be worsen? If not, what is he trying to say? c-J, check your transcription. Maybe you left out something important.
Then there's the statement:
"In all cases, the self capacitance of a coil has an apparent effect on its true DCR, true inductance & true Q of the coil itself & at frequencies considerably below the self resonant frequency of the coil."
How? Why? I'm sure that the part about 'considerably below the self resonant frequency of the coil' offers an important clue, but at the moment I don't see it. c-J, did you skip an entire paragraph?
How about telling us where you got this. Obviously it's a printed book, as you had to retype it. Who's the author and what's the title? Maybe someone else has a copy and can offer some insight.
-- Dave
Oh, I almost forgot:
"Quiz: why common mode chokes are typically built of two coils of a few loosely wound wires?"
Whether or not they are typically built that way depends entirely on the intended use of the choke. But, I think I know where you're trying to go. In reply I offer a quiz for you:
1) How is the performance of a CM choke affected by capacitance between windings?
2) Does capacitance between either winding and ground have the same affect?
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Re: The neglected factor: self-capacitance of coils ? - Dave Cigna 16:55:35 12/05/06 (55)
- Better read more books, bud. - cheap-Jack 08:40:51 12/06/06 (54)
- Answers to quiz questions - Dave Cigna 18:10:14 12/06/06 (53)
- Re: Answers to quiz questions - dave slagle 11:32:12 12/07/06 (2)
- Re: Answers to quiz questions - Dave Cigna 16:28:03 12/07/06 (1)
- Re: Answers to quiz questions - dave slagle 18:14:39 12/07/06 (0)
- Are you talking about CM choke or coil winding in general? - cheap-Jack 08:12:02 12/07/06 (13)
- Re: Are you talking about CM choke or coil winding in general? - Dave Cigna 16:16:40 12/07/06 (12)
- Sorry be "rude" again, I want more relevant answer than this. - cheap-Jack 09:22:41 12/08/06 (11)
- Re: Sorry be "rude" again, I want more relevant answer than this. - Dave Cigna 17:36:11 12/08/06 (10)
- Here is what I get from your 'teaching'. - cheap-Jack 19:58:32 12/08/06 (9)
- Ok - Dave Cigna 15:13:26 12/10/06 (2)
- The concept is simple, but .. - cheap-Jack 09:53:21 12/11/06 (1)
- Re: The concept is simple, but .. - Dave Cigna 16:40:48 12/11/06 (0)
- How can you be so confused? - Russ57 08:35:08 12/10/06 (4)
- Re: How can you be so confused? - dave slagle 18:34:06 12/10/06 (0)
- I double Dog dare you... - NoWay 17:56:12 12/10/06 (2)
- I guess we can say - Russ57 11:58:05 12/11/06 (1)
- Re: I guess we can say - NoWay 14:26:16 12/11/06 (0)
- As Henry would say... - Dave Cigna 06:33:22 12/09/06 (0)
- That's some fine Mole Whacking there Dave - NoWay 03:28:22 12/07/06 (0)
- Great job - Russ57 19:05:38 12/06/06 (34)
- Leave lip service behind, please. - cheap-Jack 09:05:48 12/07/06 (1)
- No reference that would satisfy you - Russ57 10:49:19 12/07/06 (0)
- Re: Great job - fatbottle 01:48:29 12/07/06 (0)
- Re: Great job - dave slagle 06:01:56 12/07/06 (21)
- Yes, balanced power irons do NOT guarantee symmetry. - cheap-Jack 08:21:36 12/07/06 (20)
- Re: Yes, balanced power irons do NOT guarantee symmetry. - fatbottle 08:30:09 12/07/06 (19)
- Wrong shot! Dave Slagle is the "expert" to answer you. - cheap-Jack 08:36:32 12/07/06 (18)
- 'Yes, balanced power irons do NOT guarantee symmetry' - fatbottle 08:44:17 12/07/06 (17)
- "Not too clever " of you either to call me "expert" - cheap-Jack 08:59:20 12/07/06 (16)
- A schematic for the expert - fatbottle 10:00:32 12/07/06 (14)
- Have you read Thomas Mayer 's posts? - Russ57 12:08:56 12/08/06 (9)
- Re: Have you read Thomas Mayer 's posts? - dave slagle 15:32:08 12/08/06 (7)
- Re: Have you read Thomas Mayer 's posts? - fatbottle 16:58:07 12/08/06 (6)
- Re: Have you read Thomas Mayer 's posts? - dave slagle 19:12:42 12/08/06 (5)
- Re: Have you read Thomas Mayer 's posts? - fatbottle 15:03:08 12/09/06 (4)
- Re: Have you read Thomas Mayer 's posts? - dave slagle 18:21:44 12/10/06 (3)
- Re: Have you read Thomas Mayer 's posts? - fatbottle 03:50:28 12/11/06 (2)
- Re: Have you read Thomas Mayer 's posts? - dave slagle 07:53:30 12/11/06 (1)
- Re: Have you read Thomas Mayer 's posts? - fatbottle 11:37:21 12/11/06 (0)
- yes - fatbottle 13:31:05 12/08/06 (0)
- Sorry to be "rude" again. - cheap-Jack 09:14:41 12/08/06 (3)
- $650 an hour Expert hahahahaha !!!!!!!!! - fatbottle 10:31:59 12/08/06 (2)
- Don't you know you're a kiddie mental case. - cheap-Jack 08:46:11 12/14/06 (1)
- I'd rather be a kiddie mental case than a stalking troll - fatbottle 10:17:33 12/14/06 (0)
- Please explain why balanced power irons do not guarantee symetry - fatbottle 09:13:23 12/07/06 (0)
- I have been using balanced power for years - Russ57 04:44:12 12/07/06 (8)
- Re: I have been using balanced power for years - fatbottle 05:23:35 12/07/06 (7)
- In case you don't know, ... - cheap-Jack 08:49:28 12/07/06 (6)
- That is your opinion but it is 'apple and orange' as you would say - fatbottle 09:22:55 12/07/06 (5)
- I'll add one small but important point - Russ57 16:43:42 12/07/06 (4)
- Re: I'll add one small but important point - dave slagle 18:32:34 12/07/06 (2)
- Yea, unbalanced centre-tapped power won't help much. - cheap-Jack 08:52:36 12/08/06 (0)
- What would you propose as an experiment? - Russ57 04:39:08 12/08/06 (0)
- Re: I'll add one small but important point - fatbottle 17:03:01 12/07/06 (0)