In Reply to: RCA SACD feedback posted by hairydog on July 21, 2006 at 06:56:20:
...a dozen and given away all but one. All my listening was done in multichannel SACD, and my MC system is set up to, first, sound great in 2-channel; you may see my system linked.The earlier 2-channel versions are sonically the worst in that they sound very Left/Right with little or nothing in the middle of the orchestra. Even the 3-channel Saint-Seans Sym. 3 (recorded in one the the finest-sounding concert halls in the world, Boston Symphony Hall), is excessively 'mono-ized', in that I get no feeling that we're listening to an orchestra spread fully across the stage--it's violins on the far left, winds in the narrow middle, and brass and bass on the far-right. They're rather like the EMI recordings the Beatles and other rockers did in the '60s and later--left telefone booth and right telefone booth.
One 2-channel recording done by the masterful Kenneth Wilkinson in England, sounds EXCELLENT--Jasch Heifitz playing Max Bruch's VC1 and Scottish Fantasy...#82876-71622-2.
I have no trouble with any tape hiss, dropouts, etc. The condition of the master tapes and the quality of the remasterings are excellent--it's the original recordings I don't like the sound of.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- I am, overall, disappointed in them. I've purchased perhaps... - jeffreybehr 10:28:38 07/21/06 (12)
- Mercury SACD? and further comments - docw 16:54:56 07/21/06 (11)
- Just got a Merc and an RCA- I like both - hairydog 07:17:08 07/24/06 (10)
- did you have left and right only with no center? - docw 16:04:56 07/24/06 (9)
- Just to add to the confusion :) - Ted Smith 14:59:12 07/26/06 (0)
- Re: did you have left and right only with no center? - hairydog 16:17:21 07/25/06 (7)
- Duh!!! - Kal Rubinson 07:24:05 07/26/06 (2)
- Re: Duh!!! - hairydog 11:36:29 07/26/06 (1)
- Re: Duh!!! - Kal Rubinson 12:45:42 07/26/06 (0)
- gave you the wrong impression... - docw 17:44:10 07/25/06 (3)
- Re: gave you the wrong impression... - hairydog 06:05:51 07/26/06 (2)
- you don't accept email, so send me one if you care re ebay record folks - docw 11:48:52 07/26/06 (0)
- agree with your conclusions... - docw 06:52:34 07/26/06 (0)