In Reply to: John, you were sucker-punched, then piled on, by the Usual Suspects. posted by clarkjohnsen on June 7, 2003 at 08:26:09:
Clark:Your article had some good points, but with comments like this, I for one can find little, if any, reason to lend you any respect whatsoever. I'm well aware that you don't give one hoot what I think of you, but I need to say this nonetheless.
The comment is a classic example of the BIG LIE. Curl is notorious for the way in which he abuses and attacks people. Jneutron consistently is polite and attempts to engage in reasonable dialog that is the normal approach in most academic and scientific settings. He seeks to present his data and theories, asks for others to do the same and for all to work together to arive at the truth, regardless of what it turns out to be.
I publicly challenge you to show in any small way how or why my characterization of jneutron is other than completely accurate.
Just because you have the gaul to call black white and white black doesn't make it so.
I know that whether one accepts my characterizations as accurate depends entirely on one's viewpoints, and I already know pretty much in advance who will agree with me and who won't. Nonetheless, when I see such abuse of truth and reason as is represented by your comment I will not keep my mouth shut.
What perhaps more people will agree with, who don't necessarily accept what I just said, is my further opinion that personal jabs such as your comment, designed to place people into two opposite waring camps and designate the goods and the bads, simply distract and seriously detract from any posibility that this forum can ever be a special place dedicated to free, open dialoged whose only aim is the fearless pursuit of the truth. That's what I would like to see this place become. I wonder how many others share that desire.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Re: John, you were sucker-punched, then piled on, by the Usual Suspects. - Phil Tower 10:56:45 06/07/03 (49)
- I leave the reply to JC himself, to whom your discourse is more properly directed. Except... - clarkjohnsen 10:31:56 06/08/03 (0)
- Re: John, you were sucker-punched, then piled on, by the Usual Suspects. - john curl 08:52:26 06/08/03 (46)
- Re: John, you were sucker-punched, then piled on, by the Usual Suspects. - Phil Tower 05:53:43 06/09/03 (4)
- Well, we know this one won't fly... - FairyTale 06:08:11 06/09/03 (3)
- OOPs.. - jneutron 07:28:39 06/09/03 (2)
- But they still don't believe in 'em - FairyTale 10:48:51 06/09/03 (1)
- Re: But they still don't believe in 'em - jneutron 11:28:03 06/09/03 (0)
- TSK TSK John Curl....perhaps you should carefully read the questions - jneutron 15:11:20 06/08/03 (4)
- Re: TSK TSK John Curl....perhaps you should carefully read the questions - john curl 15:31:18 06/08/03 (3)
- Re: TSK TSK John Curl....perhaps you should carefully read the questions - jneutron 15:53:25 06/08/03 (2)
- Re: TSK TSK John Curl....perhaps you should carefully read the questions - john curl 17:15:07 06/08/03 (1)
- Now THAT is the John Curl I'm used to seeing. - jneutron 05:55:58 06/09/03 (0)
- Re: John, you were sucker-punched, then piled on, by the Usual Suspects. - Steve Eddy 10:00:01 06/08/03 (35)
- Hi Steve.. - jneutron 07:02:51 06/09/03 (0)
- Re: John, you were sucker-punched, then piled on, by the Usual Suspects. - john curl 15:19:09 06/08/03 (31)
- Re: John, you were sucker-punched, then piled on, by the Usual Suspects. - john curl 22:29:57 06/08/03 (0)
- Re: John, you were sucker-punched, then piled on, by the Usual Suspects. - john curl 22:22:12 06/08/03 (28)
- Re: John, you were sucker-punched, then piled on, by the Usual Suspects. - Steve Eddy 23:57:14 06/08/03 (27)
- Re: John, you were sucker-punched, then piled on, by the Usual Suspects. - john curl 01:06:25 06/09/03 (25)
- Re: John, you were sucker-punched, then piled on, by the Usual Suspects. - Steve Eddy 09:49:38 06/09/03 (24)
- Re: John, you were sucker-punched, then piled on, by the Usual Suspects. - john curl 10:44:03 06/09/03 (23)
- Re: John, you were sucker-punched, then piled on, by the Usual Suspects. - john curl 15:49:23 06/09/03 (21)
- Re: John, you were sucker-punched, then piled on, by the Usual Suspects. - Steve Eddy 16:35:25 06/09/03 (20)
- Re: John, you were sucker-punched, then piled on, by the Usual Suspects. - john curl 18:02:06 06/09/03 (19)
- Re: John, you were sucker-punched, then piled on, by the Usual Suspects. - Steve Eddy 19:01:12 06/09/03 (18)
- Re: John, you were sucker-punched, then piled on, by the Usual Suspects. - john curl 21:33:37 06/09/03 (17)
- Re: John, you were sucker-punched, then piled on, by the Usual Suspects. - Steve Eddy 21:56:59 06/09/03 (16)
- Re: John, you were sucker-punched, then piled on, by the Usual Suspects. - john curl 00:56:09 06/10/03 (15)
- Re: John, you were sucker-punched, then piled on, by the Usual Suspects. - Steve Eddy 11:11:43 06/10/03 (13)
- Re: John, you were sucker-punched, then piled on, by the Usual Suspects. - john curl 15:06:35 06/10/03 (0)
- Re: John, you were sucker-punched, then piled on, by the Usual Suspects. - john curl 14:30:29 06/10/03 (11)
- Re: John, you were sucker-punched, then piled on, by the Usual Suspects. - Steve Eddy 15:52:01 06/10/03 (10)
- This is depressing... - Charles Hansen 07:58:42 06/11/03 (9)
- Re: This is depressing... - john curl 00:11:00 06/12/03 (0)
- Re: This is depressing... - Steve Eddy 10:52:27 06/11/03 (1)
- Huh? - Charles Hansen 13:05:23 06/11/03 (0)
- I don't know who you are either... - Monstrous Mike 10:44:59 06/11/03 (4)
- Charles Hansen - Manufacturer, Ayre Acoustics, Inc. - Leisure7 12:42:45 06/11/03 (3)
- Re: Charles Hansen - Manufacturer, Ayre Acoustics, Inc. - Monstrous Mike 09:15:15 06/12/03 (0)
- Re: Charles Hansen - Manufacturer, Ayre Acoustics, Inc. - Steve Eddy 12:56:00 06/11/03 (1)
- Agree - Leisure7 15:42:32 06/12/03 (0)
- No, I don't think so..There are relevant, unanswered questions.. - jneutron 09:06:48 06/11/03 (0)
- Re: John, you were sucker-punched, then piled on, by the Usual Suspects. - john curl 09:38:32 06/10/03 (0)
- Re: John, you were sucker-punched, then piled on, by the Usual Suspects. - Steve Eddy 12:07:00 06/09/03 (0)
- Re: John, you were sucker-punched, then piled on, by the Usual Suspects. - john curl 01:06:08 06/09/03 (0)
- Re: John, you were sucker-punched, then piled on, by the Usual Suspects. - Steve Eddy 18:24:20 06/08/03 (0)
- I need to get me some of those magnets... - Leisure7 12:21:17 06/08/03 (1)
- Re: I need to get me some of those magnets... - Steve Eddy 14:19:34 06/08/03 (0)
- In case you weren't sure, I for one agree with you...nt - Monstrous Mike 11:04:11 06/07/03 (0)