In Reply to: let's try to understand the point (even though we're way off track now) posted by evector on September 18, 2005 at 17:58:28:
*** you already have access to an LPCM 2.0 track from the DVD-A side of the disc, yet you're frustrated that you can't access a separate, but probably identical, LPCM 2.0 track on the DVD-V side of that same disc. ***the disc back cover advertises "2 high resolution stereo tracks", so i'm not sure these are identical - would be interesting to do a bit by bit comparison.
there's a possibility that the LPCM track on the DVD-Video section may not be watermarked, if so then yes, i would be frustrated at not being able to access it easily.
*** that would be a DVD-V player with an audio selection button. ;) ***
No, you are still not listening, or evading the issue. We are specifically talking about the ability of a player to switch between DVD-Video and DVD-Audio content on the same disc, without using a display. That would NOT be using an audio selection button.
*** if the DVD-V side audio content is referenced by a DVD-A group ***
According to Neil Wilkes, in a previous post, this is impossible. The content needs to be duplicated, not referenced. Personally, I'm not sure, I thought it was possible too, but then I defer to Neil since he authors DVD-A for a living!
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Not sure - Christine Tham 18:27:26 09/18/05 (23)
- Re: Not sure - Neil Wilkes 12:05:05 09/19/05 (5)
- thanks for chiming in. - evector 13:22:57 09/19/05 (4)
- Re: thanks for chiming in. - Neil Wilkes 08:14:40 09/20/05 (3)
- Are you able to create a very small "test" ISO image - Christine Tham 19:17:58 09/20/05 (1)
- Re: Are you able to create a very small "test" ISO image - Neil Wilkes 10:27:51 09/21/05 (0)
- thanks for clearing up the air and offering more detail. - evector 14:59:53 09/20/05 (0)
- Re: Not sure - evector 19:37:17 09/18/05 (2)
- If you look in earlier posts - Christine Tham 19:46:06 09/18/05 (1)
- Re: If you look in earlier posts - Martin419 02:03:54 09/20/05 (0)
- Re: Not sure - evector 19:26:31 09/18/05 (13)
- How does that help? - Christine Tham 19:32:46 09/18/05 (12)
- Re: How does that help? - evector 19:45:26 09/18/05 (11)
- How can that be so when they are on different sides? - Christine Tham 19:46:52 09/18/05 (10)
- Re: How can that be so when they are on different sides? - evector 20:28:22 09/18/05 (9)
- Well, you haven't actually proven anything... - Christine Tham 20:39:25 09/18/05 (8)
- and you haven't disproved anything either - evector 10:39:59 09/19/05 (7)
- I said i wasn't sure, so i don't have to prove anything ... - Christine Tham 15:06:59 09/19/05 (6)
- Re: I said i wasn't sure, so i don't have to prove anything ... - evector 20:20:06 09/19/05 (5)
- well, the point was your examples don't demonstrate anything ... - Christine Tham 05:56:30 09/20/05 (4)
- apparently neither do your posts ... - evector 15:35:51 09/20/05 (3)
- And to complete the circle ... - Christine Tham 19:12:37 09/20/05 (2)
- oh by the way - Christine Tham 21:14:20 09/20/05 (1)
- Mrs. Ultrasensitive - DangAudiophiles 09:31:26 10/02/05 (0)