Oh yeah....

Posted by Sordidman (A) on September 29, 2008 at 16:10:04

In Reply to: It's hard to really know what an artist's intentions are... posted by SF tech on September 24, 2008 at 23:42:17:

You're absolutely right, and I would hope that that foundation is definitely there in our speculations and comments surrounding the thread.

I guess at the end of the day, my opinionated point was that "24 Hour Party People" was a better representation of the group and events; and was far more interesting to me, (FWIW), than "Control:" which left off the art, and the character development that was more prevelant in "24HPP."

But as you say, what do I know? And, one can't even get close to understanding, and asserting an understanding of intentions from such a far away position. (And that definitely holds true even though it may come from similar people, in a similar position, around the same time period).

Cheers,

If you think you're going to faint, go out in the hallway

This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - Dave C: point of follow up from Posts below re: JD - Sordidman 09:26:51 09/20/08 (22)

It's hard to really know what an artist's intentions are... - SF tech 23:42:17 09/24/08 (1)

Oh yeah.... - Sordidman 16:10:04 09/29/08 (0)

errr... I'm ready for my close up now... - dave c 14:31:33 09/22/08 (6)

Thanks for your comments; - Sordidman 13:51:28 09/23/08 (3)

not wishing to appear rude, but I probably will be taken that way... - dave c 14:24:33 09/23/08 (2)

RE: not wishing to appear rude, but I probably will be taken that way... - Sordidman 15:33:09 09/23/08 (1)

Leeds you say... - dave c 21:39:40 09/23/08 (0)

RE: errr... I'm ready for my close up now... - Squonk 15:00:43 09/22/08 (1)

"every man and woman a star" - dave c 15:04:02 09/22/08 (0)

Thanks DaveC: looking forward to your comments - Sordidman 20:23:03 09/20/08 (9)

It's going to be tomorrow... I may not be at my most sensible... - dave c 07:05:49 09/21/08 (8)

RE: It's going to be tomorrow... I may not be at my most sensible... - Squonk 09:13:02 09/22/08 (7)

bloody hell, it's not exactly the second coming you know! - dave c 13:34:50 09/22/08 (6)

Settle down you old Geezer. - Squonk 09:05:22 09/23/08 (5)

Jeeeeeeeezzzzzz..... - dave c 14:25:42 09/23/08 (4)

LMAO! - Squonk 14:57:31 09/23/08 (3)

Serious as... - dave c 15:17:19 09/23/08 (2)

Very impressive Dave. - Squonk 17:44:53 09/23/08 (1)

ground control to major dude... - dave c 21:48:37 09/23/08 (0)

Joy Division: only a northern song - dave c 14:07:45 09/20/08 (0)

Wow. - Squonk 10:57:26 09/20/08 (1)

An Ideal for Living - Sordidman 20:06:32 09/20/08 (0)

Follow Ups

Oh yeah.... - Sordidman 16:10:04 09/29/08 (0)

Oh yeah....

Post a Message!