In Reply to: WOW! posted by Charles Hansen on April 5, 2006 at 20:41:53:
it actually helps me understand things myself to try to explain it to a non-technical person- you have to try to think in terms of pictures, not numbers...and at least Teresa admitted there was another train of thought, which is progress.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups Full ThreadTopic - More confirmation that Sony knows what they are doing, from sources other than Sony and Philips. - Teresa 04:40:20 04/02/06 (72)
- Nothing in this life is perfect. PCM has its flaws, so does DSD - crooner 00:34:52 04/03/06 (6)
- I could use new strings on my Guitar, it still plays and sounds fine though - Teresa 03:48:45 04/03/06 (5)
- Teresa do you still have your old CDs? - crooner 18:58:43 04/03/06 (2)
- Re: Teresa do you still have your old CDs? - No all have been sold here, on AudiogoN and eBay - Teresa 20:04:06 04/03/06 (1)
- Error in above post. - Teresa 01:05:44 04/06/06 (0)
- Teresa you should try the new Squeezebox 3 - crooner 16:41:37 04/03/06 (1)
- I'll pass thanks! (nt) - Teresa 20:19:32 04/03/06 (0)
- Just for fun, I implemented the algorithm I posted earlier in Excel - Christine Tham 15:53:15 04/02/06 (4)
- Third example: Sine wave at 1kHz at 64fs - Christine Tham 16:24:27 04/02/06 (2)
- you do realize that the range of your algorithm... - tunenut 16:33:07 04/02/06 (1)
- Actually, it's not *my* algorithm, but it does assume the input is normalised to -1 to 1 (nt) - Christine Tham 16:36:29 04/02/06 (0)
- Here's another example - Sine wave at 20kHz at 64fs - Christine Tham 16:13:25 04/02/06 (0)
- Re: More confirmation that Sony knows what they are doing, from sources other than Sony and Philips. - Dave Kingsland 14:17:54 04/02/06 (13)
- It was a good try -- really, it was! - Charles Hansen 19:46:18 04/02/06 (11)
- Charles you also cannot ignore the inverters of DSD and pretend to know more. - Teresa 19:52:35 04/02/06 (10)
- OK...it's about time to 'agree to disagree'.... - Chris Garrett 20:47:39 04/02/06 (7)
- Digital Techno-Harpies Might Just Fly the Coop!... - Waldteufel 13:52:11 04/04/06 (0)
- Yes Chris why not close this thread as it's three people against the inventors of DSD and I'm stuck in the middle! - Teresa 20:59:59 04/02/06 (5)
- Re: Yes Chris why not close this thread as it's three people against the inventors of DSD and I'm stuck in the middle! - azure 07:11:05 04/03/06 (4)
- That's when the Sony guys came out to refute that paper, but claimed it was really 'quasi-8 bit'.... - Chris Garrett 19:52:38 04/03/06 (3)
- Re: That's when the Sony guys came out to refute that paper, but claimed it was really 'quasi-8 bit'.... - Beauregard 23:38:37 04/03/06 (2)
- Re: That's when the Sony guys came out to refute that paper, but claimed it was really 'quasi-8 bit'.... - graemme 16:27:12 04/04/06 (1)
- Thank you! And no need to bother with the reference... - Beauregard 22:52:48 04/04/06 (0)
- I give up Teresa -- you're right. I'm an "ass". - Charles Hansen 20:19:36 04/02/06 (1)
- He gave a technical writer the raw materials to write the White Paper, yes - Teresa 20:46:30 04/02/06 (0)
- These are Sony’s rules not mine I didn’t invent DSD, that's between you Dr. Yoshio Yamasaki and Sony. - Teresa 18:55:22 04/02/06 (0)
- Hey, its no longer April Fools... you can quit now :) [nt] - Steve Cortez 06:29:06 04/02/06 (45)
- So Frank and Tunenut were playing an April Fools joke on me causing me to do all this research? - Teresa 06:42:41 04/02/06 (44)
- Re: So Frank and Tunenut were playing an April Fools joke on me causing me to do all this research? - azure 08:38:43 04/02/06 (43)
- Thanks so much that is very good to know! - Teresa 08:58:48 04/02/06 (42)
- Here's a pdf file to read - tunenut 10:00:22 04/02/06 (41)
- What is wrong with you? - Charles Hansen 10:16:50 04/02/06 (40)
- This one didn't disagree with Sony either! (nt) - Teresa 19:14:51 04/02/06 (0)
- I honestly don't know - tunenut 10:52:53 04/02/06 (38)
- the pdf you provided "A Brief Introduction to Sigma Delta Conversion does not disagree with Sony, in fact it: - Teresa 19:24:38 04/02/06 (37)
- please examine the block diagrem in Figure 1 - tunenut 19:28:21 04/02/06 (36)
- I prefer text but I am looking at the Figure 1 right now - Teresa 19:47:41 04/02/06 (35)
- The DAC in the diagram.. - Frank.. 00:08:09 04/03/06 (2)
- Frank I read about this that the best performace is when you use the same DAC for both recording and playback. - Teresa 04:03:35 04/03/06 (1)
- It would. - Frank.. 04:45:22 04/03/06 (0)
- and there's your problem right there - tunenut 20:29:55 04/02/06 (31)
- so in that case nowhere in that pdf does it discuss - Teresa 20:50:15 04/02/06 (30)
- sorry this time I really am done - tunenut 21:02:40 04/02/06 (29)
- Yes I have but I am only the go-between here, it is you against the designers of DSD. - Teresa 21:33:14 04/02/06 (0)
- BTW a blast from the past - tunenut 21:32:17 04/02/06 (27)
- Do you remember it because Demery proved you wrong in the same breath he said you were right? - Teresa 21:50:38 04/02/06 (26)
- Re: Do you remember it because Demery proved you wrong in the same breath he said you were right? - Dave Kingsland 06:08:36 04/03/06 (20)
- Curious, so why are they not the same thing? - Teresa 06:56:19 04/03/06 (19)
- OK here goes the ultra simple version - tunenut 09:53:58 04/03/06 (18)
- Re: OK here goes the ultra simple version - Teresa 00:14:44 04/05/06 (10)
- you are almost there - tunenut 06:39:51 04/05/06 (8)
- As I have said before it is not my propositions (I am in the middle) It is you not agreeing with these other pdf files. - Teresa 16:38:07 04/05/06 (1)
- BTW one more point - tunenut 09:17:20 04/05/06 (6)
- As I said before I don't have any misunderstanding that is between you and the writers of the pdf's and other documents. - Teresa 16:48:21 04/05/06 (5)
- Re: As I said before I don't have any misunderstanding that is between you and the writers of the pdf's and other docume - tunenut 17:00:15 04/05/06 (4)
- Finally; logic sans ego...thanks for pulling the weeds(nt) - Waldteufel 11:02:52 04/13/06 (0)
- DOUBLE WOW!! - Metralla 21:14:47 04/05/06 (0)
- WOW! - Charles Hansen 20:41:53 04/05/06 (1)
- I think it's about beaten to death - tunenut 21:18:16 04/05/06 (0)
- Still not correct.. - Frank.. 06:35:10 04/05/06 (0)
- Very nice explanation! - Charles Hansen 21:46:19 04/03/06 (6)
- thank you - tunenut 08:50:40 04/04/06 (2)
- You are a moron :-) - Christine Tham 22:30:16 04/04/06 (1)
- LOL! - Charles Hansen 20:37:58 04/05/06 (0)
- Agreed - both of you have been very helpful - Metralla 05:55:03 04/04/06 (2)
- Ditto...Even if Teresa didn't learn anything...I did; nt - Pacman 12:47:24 04/04/06 (1)
- I learned there are two trains of thought on this issue and I have decided to accept neither one - Teresa 16:53:45 04/05/06 (0)
- Demery is full off marketing junk. - Frank.. 23:46:37 04/02/06 (4)
- Frank I no longer care. The engineers can argue all they want. (nt) - Teresa 16:59:32 04/05/06 (3)
- I'm pretty sure the engineers aren't the ones who are aguing. - Charles Hansen 22:45:41 04/05/06 (2)
- Not according to the Internet - Teresa 23:43:44 04/05/06 (1)
- Sounds good to me - Charles Hansen 07:55:58 04/06/06 (0)
Follow Ups
- I think it's about beaten to death - tunenut 21:18:16 04/05/06 (0)