In Reply to: any comments then from all the Merc fans? such as Teresa? nt posted by docw on October 25, 2005 at 12:48:46:
I am a huge fan of the MLP recordings. IMHO, these are possibly the best classical recordings ever made. However, some of the MLP recordings are closely miked and will sound too forward and bright in some systems.I believe 15 out of the 20 MLP SACDs are direct to DSD transfers from 2 and 3 channel magnetic tape. They haven't released too many of the 35mm film recordings, so it's hard to generalize about how they compare to the tape recordings. But I don't think they are necessarily spoiled by the PCM conversion.
Then again, a number of my favorite SACDs are from Chesky, so I'm hardly a DSD purist.
Dave
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- I have two of the 35mm film recordings, and they sound good to me - Dave Kingsland 15:10:18 10/25/05 (20)
- "some of the MLP recordings are closely miked and will sound too forward and bright in some systems." - oscar 17:51:16 10/25/05 (0)
- I also have not heard any Chesky recordings that I liked! I got 4 or 5 and traded all in used. nt - oldmkvi 15:21:25 10/25/05 (18)
- Re: I also have not heard any Chesky recordings that I liked! I got 4 or 5 and traded all in used. nt - JMCIII 13:18:49 10/26/05 (2)
- Re: I like my Chesky's !!!!! - MikeH4 19:49:06 10/27/05 (0)
- Re: I also have not heard any Chesky recordings that I liked! I got 4 or 5 and traded all in used. nt - oldmkvi 09:59:14 10/27/05 (0)
- I'm with Dave on this one - Pacman 10:30:41 10/26/05 (6)
- You couldn't GIVE me a Chuck Mangion album!!!!!!!!!!!!!! nt - oldmkvi 11:08:40 10/26/05 (5)
- Tell me what you really think.. Don't be so subtle (LOL); nt - Pacman 18:23:41 10/27/05 (4)
- Re: Tell me what you really think.. Don't be so subtle (LOL); nt - oldmkvi 19:58:28 10/27/05 (3)
- Actually it's "Something Different", the group is "The Jazz Brothers". nt - oldmkvi 08:25:59 10/28/05 (2)
- I think you had it right the first time - Pacman 13:51:27 10/28/05 (1)
- Thanks- I had a chance to buy the reissue on cd but didn't- I really liked Sal Nistico-Damn! nt - oldmkvi 13:56:53 10/28/05 (0)
- Well, at least we're consistent :-) (nt) - Dave Kingsland 16:16:48 10/25/05 (2)
- I'm on an unintended negative streak here! nt - oldmkvi 16:34:16 10/25/05 (0)
- Although I did like the Telarc Dukas and Water Lily SACDs you recommended to me (nt) - Dave Kingsland 16:20:02 10/25/05 (0)
- Most Chesky SACDs are from analog... - LiquidMidrange 15:30:07 10/25/05 (4)
- I know, but they didn't do it for me, and I got some classical and jazz. nt - oldmkvi 16:01:28 10/25/05 (3)
- What do you like? - TGR 16:18:42 10/25/05 (2)
- Well, Out of the Ashes, Challenge Jazz, most Telarcs, Hourglass among many others. One - oldmkvi 16:45:02 10/25/05 (1)
- comments on yours... - docw 17:26:04 10/25/05 (0)