RE: for your information

Posted by Say (A) on May 19, 2011 at 09:33:42

In Reply to: for your information posted by Joe Murphy Jr on May 19, 2011 at 09:14:53:

so you did the test? Good. Unfortunately someone is being dishonest here. I am confident in my judgement for I don't need someone to tell me how something sounds. I do that for myself. I don't need a panel of slides to move, buttons to push or sound waves to measure. Why? Because I just heard the best Moving Pictures on cd and it is the 30th Ann. Edition. Period!

So what does our discrepancy make of our results Joe? You being the senior member at AA and me a newb. I'l tell you what to make out of it.

A) you really did not listen to the 30th anniversary edition
B) you did and you are obstinate for a reason
C) you are deluding yourself
D) you have poor listening skills.

Now if you think this version of the cd is fraught with boosted bass, jacked up highs and compression you may or may not be right. All is relative. BTW, I have fun at concerts Joe. I've been to tons. Going into my fifth decade I don't need some anonymous Joe to tell me about music. Nor do I appreciate your attempt at insults. If you can't carry on a mature and decent conversation without Ad hominem attacks than keep your disrespectful behavior to yourself and away from this topic.

We are talking about one record and one record only. Stop deviating and generalizing. In fact those who do are seldom sure of themselves instead they are full of it. If you have to then let's do it apples to apples - I believe that the MFSL gold cd of 'Permanent Waves' is the best sounding cd available. I will also state that the best sounding 'Signals' is also the one from MFSL.

This guy here also agrees with me about Moving Pictures. Not that it means anything because I am not him:
http://musictap.net/2011/04/18/review-moving-pictures-2011-remaster-cddvd-30th-anniversary-deluxe-edition-rush/

This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - Rush DVD-A ships tomorrow (4/5) - bquisp 09:25:06 04/04/11 (31)

I'm a little disappointed to be honest - ristopalazzo 19:48:27 04/16/11 (8)

RE: I'm a little disappointed to be honest - cfraser 19:25:39 04/17/11 (7)

RE: I'm a little disappointed to be honest - ristopalazzo 20:42:08 04/17/11 (6)

RE: I'm a little disappointed to be honest - Say 12:04:05 05/17/11 (5)

completely disagree - Joe Murphy Jr 21:59:03 05/18/11 (4)

RE: completely disagree - Say 06:53:44 05/19/11 (3)

for your information - Joe Murphy Jr 09:14:53 05/19/11 (1)

RE: for your information - Say 09:33:42 05/19/11 (0)

RE: completely disagree - Say 07:54:37 05/19/11 (0)

Got my copy just an hour ago! - Dman 14:36:08 04/07/11 (18)

different opinion - Joe Murphy Jr 22:02:38 04/07/11 (17)

The Blu-ray is pretty good - cfraser 10:18:17 04/09/11 (3)

thanks for the followup [nt] - Joe Murphy Jr 21:07:28 04/19/11 (2)

Did you spring for this? - cfraser 21:11:01 04/21/11 (1)

soon - Joe Murphy Jr 22:58:51 04/21/11 (0)

RE: different opinion - Dman 05:43:24 04/08/11 (12)

RE: different opinion - PdL 19:54:58 04/08/11 (1)

RE: different opinion - Dman 05:31:55 04/09/11 (0)

sounds positive - Joe Murphy Jr 09:52:08 04/08/11 (9)

RE: sounds positive - Dman 17:49:02 04/08/11 (8)

RE: sounds positive - simon wagstaff 08:55:56 05/08/11 (7)

here's a screenshot - Joe Murphy Jr 17:21:07 05/19/11 (5)

Figgers... - cfraser 19:49:30 05/19/11 (3)

can't agree with that - Joe Murphy Jr 22:02:49 05/19/11 (2)

OK - cfraser 22:19:30 05/19/11 (1)

can definitely agree with that :-) [nt] - Joe Murphy Jr 00:48:48 05/20/11 (0)

RE: here's a screenshot - Say 17:34:50 05/19/11 (0)

there's an easy way to find out - Joe Murphy Jr 10:02:43 05/16/11 (0)

RE: Rush DVD-A ships tomorrow (4/5) - rlmacklin 08:40:56 04/06/11 (2)

Best Buy has it now as an exclusive. - bqusip 12:25:22 04/06/11 (1)

RE: Best Buy has it now as an exclusive. - hwkn 19:04:41 04/06/11 (0)

Follow Ups

RE: for your information - Say 09:33:42 05/19/11 (0)

RE: for your information

Post a Message!