In Reply to: I'm a little disappointed to be honest posted by ristopalazzo on April 16, 2011 at 19:48:27:
Do you have a graph that compares the new CD included with the DVD-A? I don't prefer the sound of the CD that much myself, was a bit disappointed actually. The sound is not bad but sounds restricted compared to the BD (stereo or surround). Somehow I thought the CD and BD stereo mixes would be very similar, except for bit format of course. The difference I heard is not explained just by that, there is more going on, so perhaps the new CD is more compressed too.
Rush mentioned they recorded the BD at lower volume (than typical movies etc.) so they could get more dynamic range. I say nonsense, this BD is recorded like 10dB louder than a typical movie/TV BD is these days (15-20dB louder than WB lol) based on my regular listening level setting for DTS-HD MA (caught me quite off guard). There is still plenty of room for dynamic range, and I actually think Rush did this fairly right level-wise, it's the movie studios who sometimes record at ridiculously low levels and don't even nearly use the available DR.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- RE: I'm a little disappointed to be honest - cfraser 19:25:39 04/17/11 (7)
- RE: I'm a little disappointed to be honest - ristopalazzo 20:42:08 04/17/11 (6)
- RE: I'm a little disappointed to be honest - Say 12:04:05 05/17/11 (5)
- completely disagree - Joe Murphy Jr 21:59:03 05/18/11 (4)
- RE: completely disagree - Say 06:53:44 05/19/11 (3)
- for your information - Joe Murphy Jr 09:14:53 05/19/11 (1)
- RE: for your information - Say 09:33:42 05/19/11 (0)
- RE: completely disagree - Say 07:54:37 05/19/11 (0)