In Reply to: A Survey of the "New World" on SACD posted by madisonears on April 23, 2007 at 23:30:45:
the Szell is a great musical performance and a historical document, aside from your cavils about the recorded sound. Your impressions of the recorded sound especially regarding the Slavonic Dances is much more critical than others I have read. I own almost all that material on LP.I have been trying to acquire different formats of that performance. I think that the best thus far is the Great Performances CBS version on LP. I got a pretty good copy of the original stereo Gold Epic and the sound was really pinched (disappointment, in light of good copies of other works).
A German/Austrian version on rbcd was really weird sounding, with highs and so forth as if a blanket covered my tweeters in parts of the piece. Far worse than a Type I LN cassette copy I made of the CBS LP reissue!
Thanks for the observations. I own the Reiner SACD/CD hybrid.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- OT, but some observations on Szell - docw 11:40:40 04/24/07 (0)