In Reply to: Interesting. Any particular reason you prefer stock models? posted by Zero on October 20, 2005 at 21:55:33:
I prefer to listen to a player the way the designer intended. These days, DACs are designed to match specific op amps and specific filters, otherwise they may not meet the measured specs as per the data sheets. More often that not, stock player designs tend to stick pretty close to the Application Note.Now a modder may be able to subjectively improve the sound by replacing the output stage with different op amps, or perhaps discrete high quality components.
But is that truly better, if the measured specs are perhaps now worse? I don't know. Our ears are easily fooled - it's easy to convince ourselves that the sound is "better" when it is simply "different".
I prefer to choose a player that sounds good to me right from the start, rather than buy a player that didn't sound right and hope that i will like it if i mod it, especially if the sound wasn't what the original designer intended.
Modders (particularly those on this asylum) are fond of disparaging stock designs and pointing out flaws in them. But are these truly flaws? - we seldom get to hear the original designer's point of view. It's tempting to believe the not-so-subtle marketing messages that the modders are trying to push - I prefer not to void the warranty.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- I'm just funny that way ... - Christine Tham 15:10:14 10/21/05 (7)
- There's only one test... - Allen Wright 10:11:52 10/22/05 (6)
- if you are willing to lend me a modded and unmodded machine - Christine Tham 14:47:35 10/22/05 (5)
- Re: if you are willing to lend me a modded and unmodded machine - Joe Rasmussen 23:24:15 10/25/05 (0)
- Re: if you are willing to lend me a modded and unmodded machine - Allen Wright 03:11:44 10/23/05 (3)
- Thanks! Look forward to it! (nt) - Christine Tham 14:25:48 10/23/05 (2)
- Has Joe contacted you yet re this matter? - Allen Wright 16:33:49 10/25/05 (1)
- No he hasn't, but I'll check my email tonite (nt) - Christine Tham 01:06:52 10/27/05 (0)