In Reply to: Re: But what about the difference between lossy and lossless posted by Charles Hansen on February 28, 2007 at 12:33:10:
Hey Y'all:
Admittedly there isn't much of a market for surround sound, it is a commercial failure. But this is far from saying that it (DVD A and SACD) are pointless. They were a godsend to us surround enthusiasts, for we haven't had any new material since they quit making quadradiscs, SQ and QS phonograph records. And by the way, half speed mastering was invented for quadradisc, the fact that it benefitted stereophiles was an offshoot. Quad heads are just like any other audiophiles, we like the best sound quality availlable. But until SACD and DVD-A came along, we had to settle for what LPs. had to offer. We will take DVD-A over DTS, and we will take DTS over DD. We want the best quality but we want it in surround. Another point of DVD-Audio and SACDs is that they are mostly studio recordings not live concert recordings. They have true surround not just band up front, crowd in back. They also have just the music, like a CD, not this annoying tripe (interviews, backstage scenes) that they stick between and sometimes in the middle of songs. Surround is what we like. If you don't like that then don't buy it. But there's no need to put it down. These discs have a purpose. Unfortunately there are very few who "get" true surround sound, so we probably will be relegated to videos with DD and poor surround. At least that's something for us. And every now and then some studio comes along and throws us a bone. At least this is not like quad, where when quad was over, it was over.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Re: But what about the difference between lossy and lossless - The Quadfather 18:14:22 02/28/07 (9)
- Another red herring - Charles Hansen 20:13:40 02/28/07 (8)
- Re: Another red herring - Neil Wilkes 03:01:52 03/02/07 (7)
- Re: Another red herring - Charles Hansen 09:57:15 03/02/07 (6)
- Re: Less of a Red Herring - mwheelerk 21:10:23 03/05/07 (3)
- Re: Less of a Red Herring - Charles Hansen 09:24:11 03/06/07 (2)
- Re: Less of a Red Herring - mwheelerk 16:25:35 03/08/07 (1)
- Sad but true - Charles Hansen 20:45:12 03/08/07 (0)
- it'll be over soon - Joe Murphy Jr 11:18:42 03/04/07 (1)
- Re: it'll be over soon - Charles Hansen 12:41:08 03/04/07 (0)