Re: Classic Records Claims to NOT MLP on the 192kHz 24 Bit

Posted by evector (A) on January 31, 2005 at 15:41:00

In Reply to: Classic Records Claims to NOT MLP on the 192kHz 24 Bit posted by Teresa on January 31, 2005 at 13:04:31:

"Classic Records Claims to NOT MLP on the 192kHz 24 Bit..."

is this a documented claim? i could find no online reference to this claim.

you are correct in that based on the length of the audio program as well as an absence of a bounty of bonus material, compression/MLP might not be necessary.

that however is not the case with the only HDAD title I have: "The Alan Parsons Project - I Robot". the disc contains approximately 41 minutes of musical content and very little else on each side. it would appear that MLP would not be necessary. however, my dvd player clearly indicates MLP encoding on the DVD-A side of the disc and Liner PCM on the DVD-V side of the disc. further inspection of the disc file directory structure supports the above observations for both sides of the disc.

if you have an HDAD title, I would encourage a closer inspection.

This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - SA-DVD? A new spec without MLP? - Dad 04:22:43 01/28/05 (13)

Classic Records HDAD 192kHz 24 BIt DVD-Audio's also do no use lossless compression. - Teresa 13:02:09 01/28/05 (10)

Re: Classic Records HDAD 192kHz 24 BIt DVD - rodpaine 07:26:16 01/30/05 (1)

Re: Classic Records HDAD 192kHz 24 BIt DVD - evector 20:10:28 01/30/05 (0)

not the case... - evector 17:45:58 01/28/05 (7)

Classic Records Claims to NOT MLP on the 192kHz 24 Bit - Teresa 13:04:31 01/31/05 (4)

Re: Classic Records Claims to NOT MLP on the 192kHz 24 Bit - uzun 17:50:01 01/31/05 (0)

Re: Classic Records Claims to NOT MLP on the 192kHz 24 Bit - evector 15:41:00 01/31/05 (1)

I searched the web and couldn't find Classic Records Claim to not use MLP, however my findings say they do USE MLP! - Teresa 15:20:15 02/01/05 (0)

Re: Classic Records Claims to NOT MLP on the 192kHz 24 Bit - unaffiliated 13:17:36 01/31/05 (0)

This is interesting . . . - Martin419 09:50:04 01/31/05 (1)

Yes Martin I have the AIX sampler and the 192kHz 24 Bit recordings require a DVD-Audio player. - Teresa 15:23:02 01/31/05 (0)

$700 for a DVD? Are they kidding? - theaudiohiffle 06:09:03 01/28/05 (1)

No... - Frank.. 11:53:14 01/28/05 (0)

Follow Ups

Re: Classic Records Claims to NOT MLP on the 192kHz 24 Bit - evector 15:41:00 01/31/05 (1)

I searched the web and couldn't find Classic Records Claim to not use MLP, however my findings say they do USE MLP! - Teresa 15:20:15 02/01/05 (0)

You can not post to an archived thread.